Research Status · v2.0.0 · Reference Implementation
Dashboard
Research status and scientific maturity
A research article plus reference implementation (v2.0.0) of the orchestration architecture for the Aether family. A reference implementation is built (7 modules, 39 tests) and 3 experiments are completed on simulated data. No real-world deployment has been evaluated. F1–F4 are not falsified by the implementation or the experiments, but they are also not confirmed. F5 (observable benefit) remains untested.
7
Modules
39
Tests Passed
3/3
Experiments
20
Open Questions
Status vocabulary:
Built implementation exists
Passed tests succeeded
Not falsified weaker than confirmed
Untested no evaluation
In progress pending
Hypothesis specification only
v2.0.0 at a Glance
| Dimension | Status |
|---|---|
| Manuscript (v0.1.0) | Complete (36 pages) |
| Definitions / Propositions / Layers | 4 / 2 (proof sketches) / 5 |
| Implementation | Built src/aetherorchestrate/, 7 modules |
| Tests | 39 passed |
| Experiments | 3/3 completed (simulated data) |
| PyPI package | Published |
| Real-world deployment | Not evaluated |
| Causal claims | None (argument only) |
The Seven Functional Dimensions
| # | Dimension | Focus | DOI |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | AetherGit | Storage and versioning | 10.5281/zenodo.23966896 |
| 2 | AetherFlow | Integration and operational verification | 10.5281/zenodo.23979129 |
| 3 | AetherProof | Specification and structured evidence | 10.5281/zenodo.24013124 |
| 4 | AetherMesh | Distribution and eventual consistency | 10.5281/zenodo.24038038 |
| 5 | AetherGovern | Authority and policy | 10.5281/zenodo.24054524 |
| 6 | AetherRuntime | Monitoring and runtime assurance | 10.5281/zenodo.24078477 |
| 7 | AetherOrchestrate (hypothesis) | Orchestration | 10.5281/zenodo.24095399 |
Foundational Documents
| Document | Version | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Research Paper (PDF) | 0.1.0 | Published (Zenodo) |
| Figshare Preprint | 0.1.0 | Published (Figshare) |
| OSF Registration | 0.1.0 | Published (OSF) |
| Reference Implementation | 2.0.0 | Built (7 modules) |
| Test Suite | 2.0.0 | 39 passed |
| Experiments | 2.0.0 | 3/3 completed (simulated) |
| PyPI Package | 2.0.0 | Published |
Scientific Maturity
| Indicator | Status | Notes |
|---|---|---|
| Research problem | Specified | Orchestration gap in the Aether family |
| Central question | Specified | Four clauses mapping to F1–F5 |
| Formal definitions | Defined | 4 definitions (as layers) |
| Propositions | Stated | 2 (proof sketches, not machine-checked; A1–A6) |
| Failure conditions | Stated | 5 (F1–F5) |
| Requirements | Stated | 6 (R1–R6) |
| Implementation | Built | 7 modules under src/aetherorchestrate/ |
| Tests | 39 passed | Test suite present |
| Experiments | 3/3 | Simulated data only |
| PyPI package | Published | v2.0.0 on PyPI |
| Real-world deployment | Not evaluated | No deployment |
| Causal claims | None | Argument only |
| Peer review | Not peer reviewed | Preprint status |
Publication Status
| Venue | Identifier / URL | Status |
|---|---|---|
| Zenodo | 10.5281/zenodo.24095399 | Published |
| Figshare | 10.6084/m9.figshare.34963687 | Published |
| OSF Registration | 10.17605/OSF.IO/2F7TZ | Published |
| OSF Project | osf.io/8beur | Published |
| PyPI | pypi.org/project/aetherorchestrate | Published |
| GitHub | github.com/gitdeeper15/aetherorchestrate | Active |
| GitLab | gitlab.com/gitdeeper15/aetherorchestrate | Active |
| Codeberg | codeberg.org/gitdeeper15/aetherorchestrate | Active |
| Bitbucket | bitbucket.org/gitdeeper15/aetherorchestrate | Active |
| Netlify | aetherorchestrate.netlify.app | Active |
Structural Counts
| Category | Count |
|---|---|
| Formal Definitions | 4 |
| Propositions | 2 (P1–P2, proof sketches) |
| Failure Conditions | 5 (F1–F5) |
| Requirements | 6 (R1–R6) |
| Orchestrate Layers | 5 |
| Functional Dimensions | 7 (6 existing + 1 hypothesis) |
| Figures | 6 |
| References | 36 |
| Open Questions | 20 (Q1–Q20) |
| Evaluation Metrics | 9 (M1–M9) |
| Baselines | 5 (B1–B5) |
| Scenarios | 6 (S1–S6) |
| Threats to Validity | 7 |
| Python Modules | 7 |
| Tests | 39 |
| Experiments | 3 |
Failure Conditions F1–F5
| ID | Claim under test | Status |
|---|---|---|
| F1 | Non-redundancy | Not falsified (R2, R4, R6 partly covered) |
| F2 | Orthogonality to verification | Not falsified (narrowly) |
| F3 | Boundary with governance | Not falsified (decentralized setting) |
| F4 | Decentralizability | Not falsified (with residuals) |
| F5 | Observable benefit | Untested |
"Not falsified" is a weaker status than "confirmed". F5 (observable benefit) remains untested. Neither the implementation nor the simulated experiments promote "not falsified" to "confirmed".
Requirements R1–R6
| ID | Requirement |
|---|---|
| R1 | Goal decomposition: a goal can be decomposed into a DAG of tasks |
| R2 | Task assignment: each task can be assigned to a capable agent |
| R3 | Scheduling: tasks can be ordered in time respecting dependencies |
| R4 | Dependency tracking: the task DAG can be maintained under concurrent updates |
| R5 | Routing: each task can be delivered to its executor without a central router |
| R6 | Partition tolerance: decomposition, assignment, scheduling, and routing remain possible when nodes are disconnected |
The Five Orchestrate Layers
| Layer | Question | Status |
|---|---|---|
| L1 — Decomposition | How is a goal broken into tasks? | Implemented |
| L2 — Assignment | Which agent executes each task? | Implemented |
| L3 — Scheduling | When does each task run? | Implemented |
| L4 — Dependency Tracking | What are the dependencies between tasks? | Implemented |
| L5 — Routing | How is each task routed to its executor? | Implemented |
Propositions P1–P2
| # | Proposition | Status |
|---|---|---|
| P1 | Determinism of Local Decomposition | Proof sketch (not machine-checked) |
| P2 | Irreducible Coordination Window | Proof sketch (not machine-checked) |
Both propositions are stated with proof sketches; neither is machine-checked. They are conditional on assumptions A1–A6 (inherited from AetherMesh). They bear directly on F4 (decentralizability).
Evaluation Design (M1–M9, B1–B5, S1–S6)
| # | Metric | Direction / Constraint |
|---|---|---|
| M1 | Decomposition accuracy | Higher is better |
| M2 | False-positive rate | Lower is better |
| M3 | Decomposition latency | Lower is better |
| M4 | Assignment fairness | Higher is better |
| M5 | Schedule feasibility | Higher is better |
| M6 | Dependency-tracking accuracy | Higher is better |
| M7 | Routing overhead | Lower is better |
| M8 | Coordination window | Lower is better |
| M9 | Convergence preservation | Constraint: must be zero if P1 holds |
The evaluation design fixes M1–M9, B1–B5, and S1–S6 in advance. In v2.0.0, only M1, M4, and M8 are exercised — and only in simulation.
v2.0.0 Experimental Results
| # | Experiment | Metrics | Result |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | Decomposition Accuracy | M1 | 10 goals; mean task count = 1.00; all acyclic |
| 2 | Assignment Fairness | M4 | Jain index = 0.8803 (expected 0.9174; 4% deviation) |
| 3 | Coordination Window | M8 | 5 scenarios; all positive; min 0.008 s, max 7.5 s |
Simulation only. No generalization beyond simulation is claimed. Baselines B1–B5 and scenarios S1–S6 are not evaluated in v2.0.0.
Open Questions Q1–Q20
| ID | Status | Note |
|---|---|---|
| Q1–Q20 | Open | Spans decomposition, assignment, scheduling, dependency tracking, routing, interfaces, methodology |
All 20 open questions remain unresolved in v2.0.0. Their full statements are in Section 10 of the paper and are not reproduced here.
Threats to Validity
| Type | Threat | Status |
|---|---|---|
| T1 | Construct validity | Report several metrics; invite independent review |
| T2 | Internal validity | Equal tuning budgets; ablations; shared seeds |
| T3 | External validity | No real-world deployment; no transfer claimed |
| T4 | Baseline strength | Well-documented baselines; external configuration review |
| T5 | Scenario selection | Pre-register; independent scenario proposals |
| T6 | Author bias | Independent review and replication |
| T7 | Model assumptions | Sensitivity runs; state assumptions with every result |
Research Status Statement
| Item | Status |
|---|---|
| Document type | Research article + reference implementation |
| Version / record | 2.0.0, November 2026 · AETHERORCHESTRATE-02 |
| DOI | 10.5281/zenodo.24095399 |
| Implementation | Built (7 modules) |
| Tests | 39 passed |
| Experiments | 3/3 (simulated) |
| PyPI package | Published |
| Real-world deployment | None |
| Propositions P1–P2 | Proof sketches; not machine-checked; A1–A6 |
| Byzantine evaluation | Not performed in v2.0.0 |
| Third-party claims | As reported; not independently verified |
| Review status | Not peer reviewed |
Status note (v2.0.0): This is a research article plus reference implementation (v2.0.0) of the orchestration architecture for the Aether family. A reference implementation is built (7 modules, 39 tests) and 3 experiments are completed on simulated data. No real-world deployment has been evaluated. F1–F4 are not falsified by the implementation or the experiments, but they are also not confirmed. F5 (observable benefit) remains untested. Propositions P1–P2 remain proof sketches (not machine-checked) and are conditional on assumptions A1–A6. The paper is not peer reviewed. AetherOrchestrate is a candidate, not a result.